Sarah’s cheeks burn as her colleague leans over her cubicle wall. “That presentation you gave yesterday was incredible,” he says with genuine enthusiasm. “The client couldn’t stop talking about how impressed they were.”
Instead of feeling proud, Sarah’s stomach knots. She fidgets with her pen and mutters, “Oh, it wasn’t that good. I stumbled over the third slide.” Twenty minutes later, her boss stops by to mention she should double-check her email formatting. This time, Sarah sits up straighter. She nods, takes notes, and feels strangely… settled.
Sound familiar? You’re not alone, and you’re not broken. Psychology has fascinating explanations for why some people feel uncomfortable with praise while finding criticism oddly comforting.
The Hidden Psychology Behind Praise Discomfort
When someone feels uncomfortable with praise, their brain is often running a complex background program shaped by years of experience. This isn’t just “being modest” – it’s a genuine psychological response that can feel physically overwhelming.
Dr. Jennifer Martinez, a clinical psychologist specializing in self-esteem research, explains: “People who struggle with praise often have nervous systems that learned early on to treat positive attention as potentially dangerous or unreliable.”
Your childhood environment plays a massive role here. If you grew up where compliments were rare, conditional, or followed by criticism, your brain developed a simple rule: praise equals unpredictability, criticism equals familiarity. And our brains love predictability, even when it hurts.
The physical response is real too. When praise arrives, your body might react with increased heart rate, sweating, or that familiar urge to escape. Meanwhile, criticism activates different neural pathways – ones that feel more like “home.”
The Science Behind Why Criticism Feels Safe
Research reveals some eye-opening patterns about how different people process feedback. Understanding these mechanisms can help explain why you might feel more comfortable deflecting compliments than accepting them.
| Praise Response | Criticism Response |
|---|---|
| Increased anxiety and self-doubt | Focused attention and clarity |
| Physical discomfort (blushing, tension) | Familiar emotional territory |
| Immediate deflection or dismissal | Active listening and note-taking |
| Questions about authenticity | Acceptance as accurate information |
A 2019 study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people with unstable self-esteem literally process praise differently in their brains. The research showed:
- Negative feedback activated reward centers in people with low self-worth
- Positive feedback triggered threat-detection systems instead of pleasure responses
- Critical comments were processed as more “believable” than compliments
- The brain spent more energy analyzing praise for potential deception
Psychologist Dr. Amanda Chen notes: “It’s not that these people enjoy being criticized. It’s that criticism confirms what they already believe about themselves, while praise creates cognitive dissonance.”
How This Pattern Shows Up in Daily Life
People who are uncomfortable with praise develop remarkably consistent patterns. You might recognize these behaviors in yourself or others around you.
At work, they deflect recognition instantly. “Great job on the Miller account!” becomes “Oh, anyone could have done that” or “I just got lucky with the timing.” Yet when a supervisor mentions areas for improvement, they lean in with genuine interest.
In relationships, compliments about appearance, personality, or achievements get brushed off or redirected. “You look beautiful tonight” might be met with “This old thing?” But suggestions for change or improvement are welcomed and implemented quickly.
The workplace impact can be significant. People uncomfortable with praise often:
- Undersell their achievements during performance reviews
- Avoid situations where they might receive public recognition
- Feel more motivated by constructive feedback than positive reinforcement
- Struggle with imposter syndrome despite obvious competence
Dr. Robert Kim, an organizational psychologist, observes: “These individuals often become incredibly skilled at their jobs because they’re constantly looking for ways to improve, but they rarely feel satisfied with their accomplishments.”
Breaking Free from the Praise-Criticism Paradox
The good news? This pattern isn’t permanent. Your brain’s response to praise can change with deliberate practice and awareness.
Start small. When someone compliments you, try pausing before deflecting. Notice the physical sensations – the heat in your cheeks, the urge to look away, the mental scramble for reasons why they’re wrong. Just observing these reactions without judgment is the first step.
Practice accepting compliments with simple phrases like “thank you” instead of elaborate deflections. It will feel awkward at first – that’s normal. Your nervous system is learning a new response pattern.
Consider the source of your discomfort. Were compliments rare in your childhood? Did praise come with strings attached? Understanding your personal history can help explain why your brain treats kindness as suspicious.
Therapy can be incredibly helpful here, particularly approaches like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) that help rewire thought patterns. A skilled therapist can help you explore the roots of your praise anxiety and develop healthier responses.
Dr. Lisa Park, a trauma-informed therapist, explains: “Learning to accept praise is often about learning to trust that you deserve good things without earning them through struggle or improvement.”
FAQs
Is it normal to feel physically uncomfortable when receiving compliments?
Yes, this is a common response rooted in how your nervous system learned to interpret praise during your formative years.
Why do I trust criticism more than praise?
Your brain likely learned early that criticism was more reliable or predictable than compliments, making negative feedback feel more authentic.
Can this pattern affect my career success?
Absolutely. People uncomfortable with praise often undersell their achievements and may avoid opportunities for recognition or advancement.
Is there a difference between being humble and being unable to accept praise?
Humility involves graciously accepting compliments while maintaining perspective. Praise discomfort involves genuine distress and immediate deflection.
How long does it take to become more comfortable with compliments?
With consistent practice and awareness, many people notice changes within a few months, though deeper patterns may take longer to shift.
Should I be concerned if I prefer criticism to praise?
If this pattern causes distress or impacts your relationships and self-esteem, it’s worth exploring with a mental health professional.
Related Posts
